Students demand Free Education

in

400 students and staff from several tertiary institutions in Wellington marched to parliament today in protest against student debt, for free education, for a universal student allowance, and for higher staff wages. This was certainly one of the biggest student demonstrations in recent years.
[Report] [Photos 1 | 2]

Students are currently protesting against the reduction in public education spending all over the globe. In Germany the university of Freiburg is still occupied by anti-fees protesters. Thousands of students went on strike in Quebec, Canada, last month. And in Chile, students have clashed with riot police on several occasions over the last few weeks in their struggle against a new law that will cut education spending.

.

Comments

Re: Students demand Free Education

Kick-ass demo/turn-out.

"O.K class, who can tell me which country does have free post-secondary education; AND the highest rates of literacy in South America?"

"That's right Robyn." "Cuba"

Re: Students demand Free Education

Not to mention completely free healthcare. Castro is a bit of a heavy trade-off, I'll agree, but for competely free healthcare and education, across the board, it's almost worth it.
BTW, Sweden, Denmark, Norway and Finland all have completely free post-secondary education, Finland has 99.9% literacy (and the others are very close to it) and virtually free healthcare. Granted, their taxes are between 45%-60%, but isn't that worth it? Their salaries are also nearly twice as high (on average) which means they can largely afford these taxes, however this is where NZ differs: the Scandinavian economy is boosted significantly by the accessibility to Europe's economy.
Still, one would believe that free education +healthy workforce -> higher salaries/wages -> better products & services -> better economy = Win-Win.
Duh?!

Re: Students demand Free Education

Education is not free, it never has been. And being an activist list you people should know better - 'education' is more of a sham nowadays than it ever was. It is entirely appropriate that people pay for their so-called education given the context in which it exists - as a commodity [not for knowledge for its own sake and enjoyment, but quals for wage slavery for the majority!!].

ABANDON EDUCATION NOW!

Re: Students demand Free Education

Education is not free, it never has been.

@No shit Sherlock, hence the demo!

And being an activist list you people should know better - 'education' is more of a sham nowadays than it ever was.

@What makes you think people don't know that?

It is entirely appropriate that people pay for their so-called education given the context in which it exists - as a commodity [not for knowledge for its own sake and enjoyment, but quals for wage slavery for the majority!!].

@So given that this is the reality (and I agree that it is..), why should employers/politicians not pay for the education? Why should the "people" pay for the education, when it is employers/politicians who recieve the final product: a docile, obedient, ignorant, maliable civil society?

ABANDON EDUCATION NOW!

@No education is a good thing. ABANDON SCHOOLING NOW!. Schooling does not equal Education; in fact they are diametrically opposed to one another!

Re: Students demand Free Education

If you were so well educated, you might realise that Cuba isn't in South America. Ignoramus.

Re: Students demand Free Education

Good shit, I'm tugging along an $80,000 loan so put me down for the next march.

Re: Students demand Free Education

Ummm... Yeah, Cuba is in South America you dill hole.

Re: Students demand Free Education

In reality, you cannot expect to pay yourself a huge salary when you are not earning anything. The only way you can get a free education is not to have one - sic. That is; material science education has come to the end of its road. Social education is better acquired from experience than from books. But it must have a solid peer group for role models and guidance. With Bush and Blair among the shrewd economists like Brash, or no economies like Peters, the precedent for no education system is poor to say the least. You don’t want to lead an anarchist society into war and race based policies. So, free education may have to wait for a long time yet.

Yeah you too mate (in advance)

Re: Students demand Free Education

hey real... what?

Re: Students demand Free Education

Teena koutou katoa
Heres a catch cry you will never hear from students. "A fair livable income for all citizens of New Zealand". I wonder why that is? Something about being middle class and self interests? Well I dont know. Does anyone else know?

Re: Students demand Free Education

@maatua
yeah, there's definately a lot fo truth in what you are saying.
however, this demo was quite special in that respect. students and staff were standing side by side and cheering for each other.
(this is probably why law and commerce students never show up at student protests - they simply don't care. Money is just not an issue for them, coz they are stinking rich.)

Re: Students demand Free Education

400 students and staff from several tertiary institutions in Wellington marched to parliament on Tuesday in protest against student debt, for free education, for a universal student allowance, and for higher staff wages. This was one of the biggest student demonstrations in recent years. Anarchists huddled around a black flag and were, like most others, unimpressed by Trevor Mallard’s speech. 2005 could be the year that Victoria students and staff actually fight back against the government and the university council.

Re: Students demand Free Education

I've just shite on the street. I want fifty thousand dollars from the police to reveal which street. If money is not paid in 24hrs, I'll shite on another street. And I'll keep on doing this until the streets full of shite.

Re: Students demand Free Education

*sigh*

I want free education too, but it looks like we arent going to get it.

March all you like, wave placards, burn effergies, the government is not going to listen to you - they wont even cut fees let alone scap them entirely. All they want to talk about is a saving scheme.

All youre just doing is portraying yourselves as a bunch of middle class layabout whiners who want something for nothing, and from so-called "middle new zealand" all you will get is calls to "get a f**king job".

15 years of marches on all we get is a change in student allowance thresholds and a scapping of interest on loans while we study, not to mention a fee cap. I think that maybe you need to try something different for a change. Perhaps doing some research, dicthing the placards and making reasoned arguements.

Until then, the government is not going to listen. It never has, and it never will.

And Cuba is in the Caribbean, and technically is a part of Latin America - the collective of central and south america

Re: Students demand Free Education

Who else in this election is supporting free
education and health, putting up taxes for the rich, is backing real full-time employment and supporting decent wages for the people?

No-one. Only the Alliance.

Re: Students demand Free Education

Who else in this election is supporting free
education and health, putting up taxes for the rich, is backing real full-time employment and supporting decent wages for the people?

No-one. Only the Alliance.

Re: Students demand Free Education

maybe we could take a lesson (no pun intended) from other student struggles going on all over the world right now! For instance students in Quebec city have been shutting down the ministry of ed building (occupation) and blocking highways.

States love parades, but they sure don't like commerce being interfered with. That is the way to get their information. And of course have a well formed, simple arguement that everyone knows for when they stick a mic in your face for that 10 second clip.

Re: Students demand Free Education

@JH
but it's not only wether education costs something or not - it's also about wether it's FREE or not.
The state will never give us freedom. They channel us through an education system that turns us into slaves of the capitalists.
The Alliance might give us education that we don't have to pay for, but they will deny us freedom.

Re: Students demand Free Education

@JH
but it's not only wether education costs something or not - it's also about wether it's FREE or not.
The state will never give us freedom. They channel us through an education system that turns us into slaves of the capitalists.
The Alliance might give us education that we don't have to pay for, but they will deny us freedom.

Re: Students demand Free Education

@JH
but it's not only wether education costs something or not - it's also about wether it's FREE or not.
The state will never give us freedom. They channel us through an education system that turns us into slaves of the capitalists.
The Alliance might give us education that we don't have to pay for, but they will deny us freedom.

Re: Students demand Free Education

Kia ora me

so true about selling out. No election will deliver anything to the working class. And the education system is where the control is enforced for sure. If you want change look in your community not in govts. If you know of one thing that is chiseled in stone for the class please tell me. Title of a new song for the students "students are doing it for themselves and no one else" Dont worry I do love you all but next time you see some beneficiaries protesting........support them.

Serve the people

Its important to remember who pays for tertiary education. Its paid for out of the value created by the working class. Graduates of tertiary education should serve the working class in return for the education that the workers paid for. This has always been the case! The fees and large debts the right have introduced give no insentive for students to serve the workers, it only makes the students poor. What is needed is a system where students can get an education without being charged fees, where they get an allowance etc. But in return on graduating they serve the working class. No debt, no temporary poverty whilst studying. Instead we have an education system that serves the people.

Socialist revolution is the solution!

Re: Students demand Free Education

libertarian socialism that is..

one thing we DON'T need is a repeat of some bullshit authoritarian regime. We're hungry for democracy, we want to govern ourselves.

Decentralised Self-Governance. Community Control.
Trade Federations. Technology to liberate us from labour. Equality. Freedom. Environmentaly sustainable industries and cities.

Re: Students demand Free Education

The stories coming out now from Guantanamo Bay will make you want to eat a tennis ball. Mr Bush and Mr Blair, are in for the long winter..

Re: Students demand Free Education

Nice to see some awareness that student protest has traditionally been selfish. (Its all about preserving the power and status of priviliged well-paid white-collar workers and middle-class managers of the future, methinks).

And supporting teachers is not really overcoming this selfishness. University teachers are middle-class: they are highly-trained overqualified white-collar intellectuals with quite well-paid (relatively speaking) and high-status jobs, have an awful lot of autonomy in their jobs, a lot of them have tenure (which means long term job security), and they have a lot of control over other people (their job is to lecture students and to boss around secretaries and tutors after all), have nice junkets and overseas trips and conferences to attend all the time, and have years off just to write stuff called sabbaticals. Sure, they have been treated poorly recently, and are being sort of casualised, but they still are better off than the vast majority of us. It's only in the last few years that university lecturers are being hit by the nasty New Right policies that have been abusing us since 1984. Welcome to the real world beyond the ivory tower.

I would say students supporting working class workers on campus is a better start ie. those badly paid, de-unionised, overworked, casualised cleaners, technicians, IT workers, secretaries, office workers, cafeteria workers and so on. If you formed an alliance with them you could really shut the university down.

And bloody hell Cuba is not part of South America. It's in the Caribbean, yes, and part of Central America and Latin America, yes, but it's not in fucking South America! South America technically ends where Panama meets Colombia.

Re: Students demand Free Education

whoops, I didn't read the parent article very well, did I? I see they supported 'staff'. But which university staff did you support? I hope it just wasn't the lecturers and professors!

Re: Students demand Free Education

umm - i agree with the selfish - middle class etc stuff being said and yes not enough students and staff see it this way or are prepared to even think about it.

i just wanted to say as a university lecturer / tutor who has also been an activist since i was eighteen (yes i still do stuff). that we're not all ignorant of these issues and lifes not all that cushy for some of us (though yes it is for some). anyway, i can see why you come to these conclusions and some of them are valid, but maybe you actually dont know the full story of what its like to be a university acedemic, the work involved, the pay and conditions etc. yes more should be done to make conditions better for workers whether on campus or not.

it is possible to express your opinions without being so absolute and marginalising people you may not be familiar with you know. anyway, it doesnt really matter i guess and this is a side issue.

Re: Students demand Free Education

Shame to see compulsory student associations continuing to lie by claiming to represent all students.

Re: Students demand Free Education

shame to see the right wing voluntary people undermining student protests.
When did ACT get 500+ people marching to parliament demanding no more free student health or no student foodbank (which is want Voluntary Student membership would do).

Re: Students demand Free Education

Student health services are usually provided by institutions not associations. If they're not it can be arranged so that health is not linked to student politics.

If students are hungry they can go to WINZ or charities. Student associations' primary role should be representation, not subsidising some students' food.

All I want is accurate political representation. I don't want to be forced to join a group which claims to speak for me but says things I don't agree with. What's wrong with that?

Re: Students demand Free Education

Student health services are usually provided by institutions not associations. If they're not it can be arranged so that health is not linked to student politics.

If students are hungry they can go to WINZ or charities. Student associations' primary role should be representation, not subsidising some students' food.

All I want is accurate political representation. I don't want to be forced to join a group which claims to speak for me but says things I don't agree with. What's wrong with that?

Re: Students demand Free Education

current moves by the Australian Howard government couple privatisation of student health with forcing voluntary membership (thus not really freedom of choice) onto student associations. National Party want a similar policy - so fees can only be collected for education (not for student services or student unions).

If there were no students associations, there'd be no united voice to campaign for services like student health to be funded properly.

If the best thing the right can come up with against student poverty is charity, then they haven't come far from the Victorian era!

Re: Students demand Free Education

Where have the Nats said they want to remove the ability to charge for student services?

In most cases student health services are provided by institutions not associations, and in many cases associations have lobbied against increases in the fees charged to provide these services.

If a student is hungry should another student be forced to subsidise his breakfast? Associations have overstepped their role in attempting to subsidise some students' food costs.

Associations are supposed to represent students. If a student votes National why should he be forced to join a group which is pushing Greens policy?

Re: Students demand Free Education

so you think that students should starve.

(You fucking wanker).

Re: Students demand Free Education

If a student votes National they are fucked in the head

Re: Students demand Free Education

Get a grip Brendan. Of course I don't want to see people "starve" but you and I know that's not happening here.

I enrol at an institution why should a student association take money from me to subsidise other people's food costs? Where does this stop? Should I be forced to subsidise their rent, their transport, their power?

Subsidising other people's living costs is way beyond the role of student associations. Food banks are a political gimmick used by associations to attract attention to so-called "student poverty". However a walk through any student carpark will show you that this so-called poverty is certainly not universal and some students are actually quite well off. If students are as poor as some student politicians like to claim, why should they all be made to subsidise the living costs of a few?

Associations are political groups which are supposed to speak for their members. Their wealth redistribution activities are not justified.

Again, why should I be forced to join a group which holds views that I don't subscribe to?

Can you answer that question rather than reverting to abuse?

Re: Students demand Free Education

Dear F*** the Nats: hate to break it to you but a lot of students vote for the Nats, and other parties like United, ACT etc. A lot more in fact who vote for the Greens and the Alliance.

You might think they're "f***** in the head" but the fact is they're misrepresented by student associations pushing Green policy.

Re: Students demand Free Education

Nah like a handful vote Act and a few farmers kids come to uni and vote National cos their rich muther fucker daddies told them too.
Polls show far more students vote Labour than National, and Parties like Greens do much better with students than lunitics like Act and United or Winston first.

PS - Nats are all racists who hate maori, students, poor people and everyone but rich muther fuckers

Re: Students demand Free Education

F**k the Nats, can you produce a poll that supports your claim that "far more students vote Labour than National, and Parties like Greens do much better with students than lunitics like Act and United or Winston first"?

Regardless, student associations including NZUSA oppose tuition fees. This misrepresents students who vote Labour, National, Act, United, NZ First - all of which support some level of fees.

Students should have an individual choice about whether or not they join a student association.

Re: Students demand Free Education

students should have the choice to not live under another fucking horrible national government

Re: Students demand Free Education

They do have a say - it's called the general election. That's where people elect the political party/parties that form the government.

But student associations aren't the government. Nobody is forced to join political parties and nobody should be forced to join student associations which after all are only incorporated societies.

Re: Students demand Free Education

C'mon compulsion supporters! Where's your next argument as to why students should be forced to join political groups?