On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation, neo-colonialism and enclosure
New Zealand Minister for Trade Phil Goff has announced that talks will begin in August to begin the process of imposing a Free Trade Agreement to bind the economies of the sixteen nations of the Pacific Islands Forum together. Australia, New Zealand, Fiji, Vanuatu, Tonga, the Solomon Islands, Samoa, Papua New Guinea and a range of other small island nations together comprise the Pacific Islands Forum.
The Free Trade Area of the Pacific has been in the pipeline at the Pacific Islands Forum for years now as New Zealand and Australian capital seek to carve out throughout the Pacific new markets, cheap natural resources and a flexible and disposable labour force.
The recent year in the Pacific has only heightened the increasing tension between the interests of Australian, New Zealand and American capital and those of Pacific peoples subject to increased repression, surveillance, control and impoverishment. In Timor Leste, Tonga and the Solomon Islands Australia and New Zealand have intervened directly into the political affairs to enforce their control over these nations and curb, criminalise and destroy popular social movements.
Timor Leste
Scott Hamilton has accurately described the present situation in East Timor, where, “as [with] the Solomon [Islands], the Howard government is using military occupation and economic bullying to try to open up the economy for exploitation. The Australians want the removal of all laws that recognise the communal ownership of land, and restrict the right of individuals to buy and sell land. The communal ownership of land makes it difficult for Aussie companies to operate effectively, and also inhibits the development of local business, because it makes it difficult for capitalist banks to finance loans (how can 1,200 people take out a mortgage with ANZ to buy the stock they need to set up a hostel for tourists, for instance?).” Read More
The situation in Timor is reaching boiling point in the wake of the deaths of two political activists who were both shot by police last week. The Socialist Party of Timor has called for demonstrations against this state repression. In recent months the Australian and New Zealand led occupation forces have played a key role in intimidating and disrupting FRETILIN, the party opposing pro-imperialist Prime Minister Jose Ramos Horta, rallies by corralling the area in which the rallies are held with “helicopters, heavy armoured vehicles and armed troops”.
Tonga
In Tonga ANZAC meddling continues as New Zealand government appointed prosecutors prepare to trial the more than 700 Tongans who were arrested during the pro-democracy rally in Nuku’Alofa that attacked government buildings and offices of companies owned by the monarchy. Green Party MP Keith Locke has pointed out the hypocritical nature of the New Zealand state’s claims to support democratic reform by criticising the Foreign Minister and the New Zealand High Commissioner for refusing to meet with any of Tonga’s pro-democracy MPs.
Migrant labour
The seasonal work permit scheme that the New Zealand state introduced last year allows for increased numbers of workers in Pacific nations to come to work in New Zealand’s agricultural and horticultural industries when needed and then returned home when their visa runs out. This seasonal work scheme has been blamed for a recent Immigration Service crackdown on people working without correct visas in the far North. While the scheme will provide increases in income to poor Pacific Island communities during those seasons when Pacific work is needed, it compounds the dependency of Pacific economies and communities on New Zealand capital and the whim of the New Zealand state. Additionally it will provide an excuse for New Zealand and other regional players not to support development initiatives in the Pacific. New Zealand agribusiness and horticulturists will also be provided with an army of reserve labour that need not be sustained by the New Zealand social welfare system between their mobilisations into the proletariat.
Andre Vltchek has characterised U.S., Australian and New Zealand policy in the Pacific as wall building. The “big three”, as he describes them, are enforcing neo-colonial dependency on the Pacific nations, diplomatic control over their foreign policies, increased control over labour and people movement within the region and further ghettoisation of the island nations as they move further from regional unity (which could provide a building bloc(k) for regional cooperation and development a la MERCOSUR in Latin America) and towards a provider of cheap labour and cheap resources to ANZUS capitalism.
Resistance
Tonga and Timor Leste face serious problems in the coming year as the Tongan democracy movement and Timor’s anti-imperialist forces suffer persecution and repression. John Holloway writing on the global anti-capitalist movement asks us to theorise contemporary rebellions to capitalist rule as “cracks in capitalist domination”. The upsurge of temporal rebellions in the Pacific have stolen headlines as they appeared in the Solomon Islands, Tonga and Timor opposing foreign and dictatorial forms of power and fighting on the streets against their perceived enemies-in the Solomon’s, foreign capital and RAMSI; in Tonga state buildings and corporations owned by the monarchy; and in Timor the Australian and New Zealand occupation soldiers. While we may oppose the forms some of this opposition takes and the often-tragic effects they have, for example the deaths during the riots in Tonga, we only have ourselves to blame for this situation. Their anger is fueled by ongoing attempts by the New Zealand state and Australian state to wall them in, enclose their commons and subvert their democracy. These rebellions represent diverse yet interconnected moments of resistance to the new empire builders in the South Pacific. As Holloway says,
“Each of these cracks may seem hopeless, like banging our heads on a stone wall. But it is not so: if we bang our heads hard enough, even a stone wall begins to crack." 



Comments
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
Nice work Omar!
National's Foreign Affair's spokesman Murray McCully made a speech earlier this year in which he argued NZ foreign policy (especially to do with aid) should be more heavily focussed on the Pacific region (ie NZ's 'backyard'). http://www.national.org.nz/Article.aspx?ArticleId=10013
While McCully doesn't have the same idea of international solidarity as most indymedia readers probably have, I think activists could adopt some of his message. It would be good for us to read up more about what's happening in the countries nearby Aotearoa and become knowledgable on how NZ foreign and trade policy is hurting people. I find a lot of left folk in Aotearoa know heaps about Venezuela and Palestine (which is good and certainly important) but we should also be aware there are plenty of movements and people struggling for dignity against the ravages of colonialism, state terror and neo-liberalism in our own part of the World too.
Trotsky vs Holloway
Omar,
I don't think that Holloway is much use as a theoretical guide for the anti-capitalist movement. As you know he advocates taking power without taking capitalist state power.
This does actually amount to banging heads against walls, but the cracks occur in the heads not the walls, and it is generally fatal, although Holloway doesnt seem to notice.
In terms of what Scott wrote on East Timor (cited above) and the character of the Pacific societies covered by you above (among the last to be taken over by global capitalism) Trotsky developed a theory of 'combined and uneven development' to explain the coexistence of precapitalist and capitalist modes of production.
There is a good (if necessarily long) article on this theory and how it can be applied to the question of linking indigenous and working class struggles today, here:
http://www.fifthinternational.org/index.php?id=237,1075,0,0,1,0
Dave
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
Here is a useful critique of Holloway
http://marxsite.com/Holloway.htm
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
Holloway is important as a theorists cause the outbreaks of violence have been directed against the state and capital. In the Pacific the nation-state system operates to oversee the penetration of foriegn capital into these islands. If the state diverts from the plan NZ and Australia are imposing it faces regime change-see what happened in Timor or immense pressure and bullying as in the Solomons.
So any attempt to resist imperialism is necessarily compromised by taking state power. Is it not then better to remain on the streets, confronting imperialism outside the system it set up in the first place?
In this vein, I can't see what good taking state power would be to anticapitalist movements in the Pacific. Smashing the state (here and in the Pacific) seems the better option to me.
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
Smash state power yes.
The attacks on state and capital in the Pacific countries show that ordinary people know who runs the state and uses its power against them.
The idea is not to take their power but smash it with an alternative, the power of the armed workers and poor peasants.
As Phil Hearse in the critique of Holloway says, workers power will not be used in the same way as the bosses, but it has to be a form of class rule over the bosses. Whether you call this - a workers state or whatever - it is the concentrated power of the productive classes that takes over the 'space' of the bosses' state.
Holloway on the other hand says that workers need their own 'space'- where? Outer Space?
Dave
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
Holloway is simply saying we need to take control of spaces (areas of land, buildings, organisations, or whatever) from the bosses, rather than wrest control of the state from them. He rejects concentrated power whether it is that of the bosses, or of an elite of workers (or non-workers) claiming to act for the whole of the working class. Seems fair enough.
- Sam Buchanan
Holloway hallucinations
Seems fair enough, except when you take over the centre of town and the centralised military smashes your heads. Like Oaxaca, Mexico, last November.
If you decide to take over the workspace in your firm, picket or occupy in other words, the bosses soon call the cops to take back their space.
Space is an abstraction, an empty gesture for middle class moralists who don't want to fight.
Space is private property or workers property or something contested in between like Chavez' expropriations.
Whoever holds it holds it by centralising their power. Decentralising equals splitting forces and heads.
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
Harbinger of 2008?
Irish Greens take state power (joke):
A Greenwash for Bertie Ahern
Ireland's Green Party Sell Out
By HARRY BROWNE
Dublin.
Ireland's Green Party has agreed to go into a coalition government with
the centre-right Fianna Fail party -- despite having spent 10 days in
negotiation failing to get the larger party's agreement on several
crucial issues.
A hastily arranged Green conference secured a solid 86 per cent majority
of party members for the coalition deal, an outcome earnestly desired
and passionately sold by almost all its most visible politicians --
three of whom will pick up ministerial office, while others pick up
various government appointments.
The word "Betrayal", however, has echoed through the party and the wider
left, as the Greens go into a government that will continue to
facilitate thousands of US troops at Shannon Airport; that will send a
motorway through an archeologically sensitive area near the Hill of
Tara; that will continue effectively to privatise the country's
disastrous health service; and that will prop up the leadership of
prime-minister Bertie Ahern despite ethical and financial questions
hanging over his head (as Eamonn McCann has discussed here on
Counterpunch).
In full at;
http://www.counterpunch.org/browne06142007.html
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
The Green Party betray the petty bourgeoisie? Never!
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
Faa Goff.
Re: Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupat
lol
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
The only Free Trade US, UK, Australia, NZ know is when trade is free for them at a cost to others. This is not always obvious, it is hidden in the paper work and value exchanges.
The poor farmers and planters of Africa have been enslaven by these contracts for years, when the West was making millions out of coffee and cocoa while the poor farmers barely survive.
Poverty is a requirement under trade relations for the dominant partner to be rich and controlling. I'm glad some Pacific Islands have learned their lesson well, and they can always use alliance with China or Korea or Taiwan and Japan's whaling as a negotiating weapon against the Western monopoly.
They must also look at what attachments are tied into Aid from NZ and Australia, and is it really helping anyone...
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
The recent uprisings in the Pacific have been centered around the Pacifics resistance to China's injection into its local trade. Most of the damage done in recent riots has been to competing Chinese business interests in those regions. To ignore this point is to miss the point, and why many of these Pacific nations may choose to join in on a pacific free trade agreement.
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
The pro-democracy rally in Tonga ended in a F5 Riot which resulted in many Government buildings and almost ALL Chinese retail stores being razed to the ground.
Same issue in the Solomons, and, any other Pacific country that has had massive influx of cheap asian labour and goods.
Even the last Fiji coup had some relation to speculator investment interests from out of China into that region.
So NZ is trying to construct a free trade region in the Pacific, as well as a free trade agreement with China?
Re: Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupat
No, it's a myth that the riot was anti-Chinese. Sure, a lot of Chinese businesses got trashed, but even the Chinese ambassador to Tonga admittted only 25% of chinese businesses in Nuku'alofa were burnt down, while 70-80% of the CBD in Nuku'alofa went up in smoke. What seems to have happened is that the rioters initially targetted govt buildings and the business interests of the monarchy, went on a looting spree, set some businesses alight and the fires from there got out of hand and burnt down most businesses. ie. in the end, all businesses were targetted, not just Chinese owned.
The Tongan riot wasn't a race riot. It was a class riot. More to do with people being pissed off with their absolutist corrupt monarchy and the introduction of neoliberal capitalism in recent years in Tonga.
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
Chinese capital has been a focal point for many rioters due to the extensive meddling that China is undertaking in the Pacific. However NZ, Australian, U.S., capital is just as meddlesome except it takes often more subtle forms of control or is more deeply rooted in governance structures or the economy. We should encourage abd support the Pacific resistance to all imperialism whether from China or NZ or wherever.
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
"neoliberal capitalism" in Tonga is all about Asian business. Its just a nicer way of saying the same thing.
Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupation,
neoliberal capitalism in tonga isn't all about asian business. if it is wheres your proof?
Re: Re: On the Eve of a Free Trade Area of the Pacific – Occupat
Not really proof, but most certainly the tip of the iceberg...
Tongan MP restates concern about Asian business presence
An MP in Tonga says there should be controls to limit the number of Chinese nationals who live in the kingdom.
http://www.rnzi.com/pages/news.php?op=read&id=12682
Tonga announces the expulsion of hundreds of Chinese immigrants:
The tiny Pacific kingdom of Tonga began moves last month to expel hundreds of its Chinese residents who are victims of a recent wave of ethnic violence.
http://www.wsws.org/articles/2001/dec2001/tong-d18.shtml
China as Collateral Damage in the Tongan Crisis
http://chinamatters.blogspot.com/2006/11/china-as-collateral-damage-in-t...
China, Tonga pledge closer military cooperation:
Chinese Defense Minister Cao Gangchuan met Friday with Commander of Tonga Defense Services Tauaika Utaatu in Beijing, pledging closer bilateral military cooperation.
http://english.people.com.cn/200706/16/eng20070616_384815.html
Chinese stores looted in Tonga riots
http://www.topix.net/forum/world/tonga/T3TLOI4L90BAUFTL2
Chinese citizens evacuated in Tonga
http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2006-11/23/content_740382.htm
TONGA:Chinese loan criticised by pro-democracy movement - 16/04/2007
A bid by the Tongan government to secure a big loan from China has been criticised by the Kingdom's pro-democracy movement.
http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/s1898039.htm
Tonga and China signed Agreement on Economic and Technical Cooperation
http://www.pmo.gov.to/artman/publish/article_398.shtml
Tonga hopes Chinese tourists will help turn economy around
http://www.rnzi.com/pages/news.php?op=read&id=23389
$10 million grants allocated during Prime Minister’s official visit to China to be used to fix roads and hospitals
http://diplomacymonitor.com/stu/dm.nsf/dn/dnEB00006CFBFF8D7A852572D5003A...
Leaders tout “Look East Policy” initiative as central to strength of Tonga-China relations
http://diplomacymonitor.com/stu/dm.nsf/dn/dn66A8DA2B40543F60852572D00039...
China TV dominates Tonga's domestic network
Since May 2006, China's Central Television (CCTV) has been offering the only television service in Tonga that is broadcast free 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
http://newswire.planet-tonga.com/story.php?title=China-TV-dominates-Tong...
The Kingdom of Tonga and the Fight Against Feudalism in the Pacific Islands
Unfortunately, what we saw in November 2006 were just riots. And I hate to say it, but they were mostly ignited by racism. 80% of the downtown area was destroyed, but the original targets were Chinese businesses.
http://japanfocus.org/products/topdf/2435
Tonga will officially break its ties Monday with Taiwan when King Taufa'ahau Tupou IV unveils a large Made in China bronze statue of himself in the grounds of the small wooden beach front palace.
http://203.97.34.63/tonga.htm