I can believe the woman was upset and frustrated in her attempt to present her history of sexual abuse, but why did she try to present it as part of a very angry and potentially volatile demonstration? Of course the Police were not going to let her through and I believe this was the response wanted by the woman (and those who perhaps put her up to it).
You can not lay siege on a building and also expect entrance.
I believe the Police exercised great restraint and should be applauded. Antagonists were in their faces, shouting and the Police acted with great professionalism.
I hope the woman who tried to present her history was supported by the march organisers and helped by them to present her case in a less threatening manner, post march. But, I imagine she was supported only so far as she could be thrown up as another example of perceived rampant Police injustice.
I would also like to say that graffiti is not a valid form of expression. Especially not where free speech is easily available to all in a mass media format of which this website is an example. Graffiti is just a shameless act of vandalism.
The police had absolutely no valid reason to deny her entry. It was completely obvious that only one woman was intending to enter, for a clearly explained legitimate purpose, and the bulk of the hundreds of protesters were standing well back. Blocking her was nothing but pointless cruelty to someone in an emotionally vulnerable position. The police did a great job of showing that their problem isn't just a few bad apples.
The bulk of the protesters may well have been standing back (although I did not see that happen), but not all. Perhaps they did not wish to recognise her legitimate complaint and it is they who are at fault. Not very sympathetic behaviour given what they were there for.
Given the nature of the protest and the very apparent level of anger the Police could not have let her through as it is very easy to see that this would have precipitated a rush of 'protestors'.
It looked like a publicity stunt and probably was. If it wasn't, she should have realised that it was not an appropriate way to register her complaint at that time. The phone would have been a better method, as an example. There were other avenues open. Choosing the most public, with easily foreseeable results, does not engender much sympathy.
You may be right. But, I can't see the woman in this photo. I have no idea if it was taken while she was trying to gain entrance or not, so at this stage I am still not convinced.
Re: Justice for Rape Survivors - Kia Kaha e nga Wahine
Date Edited: 09 Mar 2007 04:39:17 AM
You can not lay siege on a building and also expect entrance.
I believe the Police exercised great restraint and should be applauded. Antagonists were in their faces, shouting and the Police acted with great professionalism.
I hope the woman who tried to present her history was supported by the march organisers and helped by them to present her case in a less threatening manner, post march. But, I imagine she was supported only so far as she could be thrown up as another example of perceived rampant Police injustice.
I would also like to say that graffiti is not a valid form of expression. Especially not where free speech is easily available to all in a mass media format of which this website is an example. Graffiti is just a shameless act of vandalism.
Comments
Re: Re: Justice for Rape Survivors - Kia Kaha e nga Wahine
Re: Re: Re: Justice for Rape Survivors - Kia Kaha e nga Wahine
Given the nature of the protest and the very apparent level of anger the Police could not have let her through as it is very easy to see that this would have precipitated a rush of 'protestors'.
It looked like a publicity stunt and probably was. If it wasn't, she should have realised that it was not an appropriate way to register her complaint at that time. The phone would have been a better method, as an example. There were other avenues open. Choosing the most public, with easily foreseeable results, does not engender much sympathy.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Justice for Rape Survivors - Kia Kaha e nga Wahine
Re: Re: Re: Re: Justice for Rape Survivors - Kia Kaha e nga Wahine
There was NO possibility of a rush of protesters.
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Justice for Rape Survivors - Kia Kaha e nga Wahine