Aotearoa IMC : http://indymedia.org.nz
Aotearoa IMC

LOCAL News :: Indymedia : Labour : Peace : Police : Prisons

If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Monday/Tuesday, November 27/28, 2006

Nuku’alofa – Our media pass was finally dropped off on Tuesday morning which allows us to get through the army checkpoint and into the city centre. The number of destroyed buildings is enormous. Most buildings are destroyed, windows smashed, burn-out cars are in the streets, many buildings have been burnt, and the shelves inside shops are empty. Two cafes are open at the moment – mainly to cater for the NZ police – everything else is shut/destroyed. A Chinese couple was cleaning out their watch repair shop. They described how people smashed the windows with rocks and bottles, came inside and took everything: money, watches, the microwave and fridge that were out the back etc. The owner was punched in the face by someone because he tried to stop the looting.
tungiarcade.jpg
No escape – scenes from a war-zone
Staff from the ‘Escape Café’, which is part of the only shopping-complex that was unharmed, told me how all the workers, around 30 of them, formed a line in front of their workplace to protect it. Just next door, a new cinema was burnt down with the remains of the theater perfect for a horror film. The Tungi Arcade, once home to numerous shops, is completely destroyed too. The Friendly Island Human Right and Democracy Movement (*) had their offices in the upstairs floor and lost everything except for one laptop, their petty cash and their chequebook which were with the treasurer on the night of the riots. They lost computers, all their files and documents, a photocopier and furniture. They will have to reorganise their organization and have relocated their office to the suburbs for the time being.

One street along, a digger started demolishing burnt-out houses. The fire damage makes a lot of the house irreparable. The Prime Minister’s windows were smashed too. The markets are still standing but nothing is bought or sold. A few men were sitting around, waiting for the rain to stop. One of them told me that Nuku’alofa looks like Iraq, like a war-zone.

On our way out of the city centre, a group of kids was playing in the empty streets. We talked to a young woman, Frances, about what had happened in town. She said she was upset about the riots and the destruction. However she is fully behind the “demo-people”; she wants change for Tonga. But maybe still with a king. Maybe not. Primarily, she wants “everybody to have the same share in Tonga.”

“Unity and solidarity forever!”
According to a local radio station, 355 people have been charged in relation to the events on 16th November. We saw police walking around outside the central police station with colour photos of people and driving off to arrest them. Some people told us that people were beaten by soldiers and police. The soldiers use their guns to hit people in the head. We were not allowed to film at the front of the police station but when we walked around the back, some prisoners started waving at us through windows and yelled out. “I need your help!” “We’re here to fight for democracy. I fight with my truth.” “Let us free.” “Unity and solidarity forever!” It turned out that people with revolutionary ideas who we wanted to talk to are in prison at the moment. Around 100 people are in the Nuku’alofa prison and others have been sent to Mu’a.

Ofa, Aivi and Futa
On Monday we talked to Ofa Guttenbeil-Likiliki of the Tonga Women’s Action for Change and Dr. Aivi Puloka, the president of the Public Services Association. We interviewed Professor Futa Helu, founder of the People’s Democratic Party, on Tuesday.

Ofa, who calls herself a feminist, talked about women’s rights in Tonga and how many men in the pro-democracy movement do not think women’s rights are important. She told us that domestic violence is a big problem in Tongan society and that it is still legal for husbands to rape their wives. Ofa wants change but said that Tongans are not ready for democracy yet but that a lot of education has to be done first.

Aivi talked about last year’s strike and how it gave birth to PSA. “Before the strike there was no PSA. There was no Trade Union movement. It was just a spontaneous reaction of dissatisfaction with the government. […] And public servants decided to walk out from work. How was it organised? It was just an announcement and everybody turned up.” After 45 days, the strike was won and pay increases between 60-80% were given to all public servants.

Futa lectures in philosophy and mathematics and has been involved in the movement for years. He talked about the split between him and other people in the pro-democracy movement in recent years and why he chose to set up a party. Futa said that the People’s Democratic Party is a leftist party who wants “real change.”

Find the NZ soldiers
We drove all the way to the airport to the Taliai Military Camp. This is where the NZ soldiers are currently based. A carload of them drove past but no one was prepared to talk to us. After taking photos for a couple of minutes we were told to stop by Tongan soldiers and told to go back to town. At the NZ High Commission, Lieutenant Colonel Darren Beck was meeting with the High Commissioner and had a few minutes for us. Not on camera of course. “There are close links [between Tonga and NZ] from a military perspective. We do a fair bit of training. In fact, there are some people linking in who have done some training in New Zealand.” Interesting stuff. The NZDF trains Tongan soldiers who beat up pro-democracy supporters in Tonga. As soon as we started asking the ‘hard’ question, the ‘WHY’, Beck thought that after all he was not the right person to talk to and he had to leave anyways. So the person in charge of Australian and New Zealand troops in Tonga, Darren Beck, is the wrong person to ask questions about A/NZ supporting a corrupt government? Al Green, the Public Affairs Officers of the Australian Defence Force who promised us an interview with Major Jim Hammett has yet to get in touch with us, too. We are hoping to speak to the NZ High Commissioner to finally get some satisfactory answers.

”If a boat ends up on a reef…
We are staying at a wonderful guesthouse only a short walk from town. Our host gave us the following Tongan saying the other day. To me it seems this sums up what most people are thinking here in Tonga:

”If a boat ends up on a reef you don’t blame the reef;
you don’t blame the boat;
you don’t blame the wind;
you don’t blame the waves;
you blame the captain.”


(*) Just to respond to one of the comments in another post: It is my understanding that the Tongan Human Rights and Democracy Movements changed its name to Friendly Island Human Rights and Democracy Movement in November last year. They still have the same contact details (except for their office obviously and their phone number might change – but email is still the same demo(at)kalianet.to).

photos: slm
text: smush
tungiarcade2.jpg
tungiarcade3.jpg
hotel.jpg
car.jpg
cashncarry.jpg
markswatch.jpg
ofa.jpg
aivi.jpg
theproffessor.jpg
eel.jpg
militarycamp.jpg
militarycamp2.jpg
playing.jpg
 
 
Comment on this article
Title
Author
  Create a new account ?
Text Format

Comment

Anti-spam Enter the following number into the box:
To add more detailed comments, or to upload files, see the full comment form.

Comments

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Malo Aupito Smush

Great stuff,and fantastic to also hear from Tongans involved directly with the struggle. Be good to also hear the voices of young Tongan men & women as they are marginalized as well.

Our families love, strength & solidarity to those arrested and in Tongan prisons.
 

Re: Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

I was a supporter of the Pro-democracy until Black Thursday. I now have changed my mind and support the Monarch.
 

Re: Re: Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Kota dont change your fucken mine just to escape from this....you should be funished too....OK
 

Re: Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

I do not know why YOU think that was good..in support of the arsonist, theives, who burn our NUKUALOFA down--over 700 lost their jobs, 6 people died...all for your so call revolution--get real the majority of Tongan do not want " BLACK THURSDAY""...700X6 (average Tongan family) - 4200 diretly affected.. about 2800-300 kids--no jobs, no money..over 100 business burn down!!! all those families & kids too how are all these kids surviving...and all for your REVOLUTION...GET REAL.. its said for us Tongan to see you Palangi & what you want to impose on Tonga... please stay in NZ and burn Auckland down & take over the government of NZ!!!
 

Re: Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

I do not know why YOU think that was good..in support of the arsonist, theives, who burn our NUKUALOFA down--over 700 lost their jobs, 6 people died...all for your so call revolution--get real the majority of Tongan do not want " BLACK THURSDAY""...700X6 (average Tongan family) - 4200 diretly affected.. about 2800-3000 kids--no jobs, no money..over 100 business burn down!!! all those families & kids too how are all these kids surviving...and all for your REVOLUTION...GET REAL.. its said for us Tongan to see you Palangi & what you want to impose on Tonga... please stay in NZ and burn Auckland down & take over the government of NZ!!!
 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Gee I wish the soldiers in Tonga could have read your article while you were still there...you have said things that are quite untrue..like..the NZDF is there to support a corrupt government...first of all they are there to help restore law and order..they cant listen to a bunch of corrupt criminals who cal themselves people's representatives..no..they have to listen to the current government...secondly the government is not corrupt ..it consists mainly of new members who have only been in their positions a short time..they have been working to facilitate political change...i'm not sure if youre just stupid and gullable ..sucked in by Clive and his gang or rioters..or if you just enjoy twisting the facts cos youre only a small time nobody and you want to say profound things...well I only wish that the Tongan soldiers beat you up too!
 

Re: Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

I could not have agreed more. Resisting arrest could have caused the beating as Police and soldiers are being authorized by law to use minimal force. I agree with 'Ofa and Futa but not Dr.'Aivi Payne. The Pro-demos have played the well educated PSA well into their hands. The demos supported last year's strike because they expected a favour in return. Well let time reveal itself and the events that will follow.
 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Friendly Island Human Rights and Democracy Movement! The name needs to be changed back to the old name of Tongan Human Rights. What Friendly Islands? After Black Thursday, I think we have scared the living day lights out of the little tourist we did have coming into the Island. You mentioned that the city looks like Iraq, well at least Iraq is at war with the likes of the United States. Tonga is at war with Tonga! So tell me then where is the Friendly Islands? Maybe if we stopped thinking like coconuts we might get the Island to what it once was.
 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Thank you Lt. Col. Beck from NZ for walking away from these idiots, good on you, you must have smelled rotten eggs a mile away because their reports stinks...
and I have a lot of respect for Futa Helu and Ms. Guttenbeil Likiliki... but as for
'Aivi Puloka.... we need to put her on a boat and ship her to a deserted island with an active volcano and lets see how she feels then standing on top of a volcano thats ready to rupture with burning burning hot lava.... ouch! maybe she'll then feel the pain that we feel for the destructions of our beloved Nuku'alofa, she needs to get a life.
 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

The sad thing about these journalists are the fact they know nothing about Tonga. A boat can end up on the reef for many reasons and blaming the captain is not one would do in anycase. What happened in Tonga is a collaspe of trust and a failure of governement, pro-demo leaders, church leaders, communities and families. We have all failed in our own responsibilities to cooperate and find solutions and put aside our differences. I believe that Tonga needs to change but it has to be done in a way that is conducive to all Tongans and not be forced upon. Our Constitution was great gift of independence. But we must improve it. We have witness the changes in the short history of our democritisation of our system. But we must pick up the pieces now and forge ahead for better things. Those involved in the 16/11 should be punished according to the law of the land. Our Police force should be well equiped and better trained and not just run up and down in the mornings and expect all will be fine and dandy. The legal communication to use the TDS should be reviewed and I know they are looking at that. All government are corrupt in some form and thats a fact whether you are in a dictatorship, democracy our anyform or shape. Fiji is again falling apart. Lets not make the same mistake again. I work for the Tonga Government and I know how difficult it is to make progress and the change was inevitable but the progress now will be even harder. Because the big question is What is socially and culturally accepted and economically effecient to provide maximum benefits for all Tongans?. I am currently overseas tfor further studies but my family is in Tonga. I called my wife to see how things were and my four year old son said...'dad the shops are burning and the people are crazy'. I hope he will not have to say that again in his life time. I hope that he will not see that again. The road ahead will be difficult, there are livelihoods which has been affected. The economy will take a further dive. But we should not be dismayed. Through the ashes of 16/11 we should all stand up for it is in our soul our land our future..'koe Otua mo Tonga ko ho'ota tofi'a'... 'God and Tonga are our inherritance'. It is now time to look at the coming of christmas as a new begining for Tonga. For it is only through our christian faith and our working together that will take us out of the ruins. As the saying goes..United we stand devided we fall. We need unity and solitarity forever to stand tall in the face of justice and peace. We need our leaders to be accountable regardless of your political beliefs. My ofa atu to all Tongans everywhere and to our families in Tonga. The boat has not sank yet. 'Oua leva e kakau he 'oku kei houhou 'a natula pea kei peaua nofo pe 'i vaka 'o vakai fakalelei 'a e nga'unu 'a natula he ko hotau fakamo'ui tene 'omai 'a e taulanga malu. Ofa atu.
 

Re: Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Malie Tangata fakamonu atu kihe ako - we can do it..what we have to do dedoctrinise 'ae me'a 'ae kau DEMO na'e fai he last 20 yrs .. we need committed people with hope and vision ke langa a'e fonua.... if people can forget about the DEMO and concentrate on economic development organisation effeciency and be free of the blame game then we will get there if people still follow the present DEMO leaders this is just the start of the end!!!! worse will cme
 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Why are all these Kiwi media, NGO and Government judge us Tonga and how we handle our problems? Didnt NZ government gave 'Akili and his Pro Demolition crew some funding? NZ Government some have funded the destruction of Nuku'alofa as these funds may have been used to pay all the criminals, buy their beers and drugs so they can do the damages they did. Oh!, and they bought the gasoline with the same money that the NZ Government gave them. Do you think the NZ Government should be responsible if it is proven that their NZAIDS was used for the Destruction of Nuku'alofa? I hope the Tongan in NZ can ask their own Government to account for the money they gave to the PRO-DEMOLITION.
 

Re: Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Bro. you should be looking at the root of the problem instead of pointing fingers at other people. The government need to reform in a way that benefits the common people. The pro-demo. movement has been at it for over 20 years now and the government is still dragging its feet. I am not condoning what happened but people are sick and tired of waiting for the change. Do the common people have to wait for another 20 years before anything meaningful is done?? Poverty, hardship and desparation will push even the most loyal of citizene to revolt.
 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

fanfavale ngangau ko mou maumau`i ae ngaahi falekoloa ke toe langa aki ho mou tenga,
oua na`a fai mai ha kole pa`anga pe ko ha feinga pa`anga ke langafo`ou aki ae ngaahi mauamu,

U.S.A
 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

SUCK in by bogus report, check the source is not a wanna be. SUCKERS
 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

The Pro-demonic mov't is a much fitted title for these bunch hypocrites and liars. They claim themselves Christians, they've been judging the gov't for so many years, but who is God going to judge? My view on their gathering at Pangai si'i on the 16/11 was liken to a demonic rituals because they've been calling on the evil spirits by their vocabularies used, b'cos what comes out of the mouth is what inside of the heart. Their hearts were so full of hatred, greed, lust, anger and murder of course. The question is Where were their faifekaus? I heard that their closing prayer was carried out by none other than Dr. 'Aivi Puloka while the smashing has already started.

I surely hope that by now your nightmares, and gnashing of teeth will make you remember that there are innocent victims who are out there suffering as a consequences of your ignorant and malicious behaviour.
 

Re: Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Okay...i'm sick of this immature ranting and pointing fingers as if it's gonna solve anything. I appreciate your right to express this contemptuous opinion however it is very dated and doesn't seem to be understanding the situation in Tonga, which is about change and structure and the conflict of people's visions for Tonga's future- not simply evil vs. "God's" good. A reminder that these conflicting opinions are in the name of love for ones country, and shouldn't (unfortunately) be the hatred of other people.
 

Re: Re: Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

We were in Nuku'alofa the week of the riots.Now things have progressed to trials. There are genuine people within the democracy movement and then there are hypocrtical monsters like Clive-pass the passport-Edwards. Its looks like Akilise and co allowed these people to hijack what was a genuine movement.The voters seemed to have short memories of Clives flipflop from imprisoner to liberator.Burning down rival's shops so that you can increase your prices by 20% has got nothing to do democracy. A dialogue needs to keep happening towards reform and its important that convictions are not misused to block Mps who may have been carried away on a single occassion but did not pre-plan the violence from re entering parliament. The PM is not blameless either-both sides played "chicken" in the lead up to the burning but i don't think they foresaw the degree of reaction. The police were pathetic leading up to and on the day. The NZ media, keith Locke etc could have written their simplistic judgements before it all happened and we are not going to change their views.

The remote prospect of Clive hanging is so delicious that it almost causes me to support the death sentance! It would be worth letting all the others off. Evil hypocrtical, unethical, thieving, exploiting, scumbag, oh and sorry now a democratic hero-I almost forgot.
Can we not cancel his NZ citizenship so that he has nothing to duck behind? I'd be really keen if he is convicted to see him struck off as a solicitor here in New Zealand (not that not having a practising certificate stopped him appearing in NZ courts after leaving our shores) Two words Mr Edwards, McDonald and Appleby. Some people remember.
 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Barone? meno3 meno3 meno2 meno2 meno1 meno1 sew6 sew6 sew5 sew5 sew4 sew4 goo7 goo7 goo8 goo8 goo9 goo9.
 

Re: Stop the State Repression of Indigenous Peoples

hi,i work in a 搬家公司 ,my injoy such as 裝潢 and 室內設計,others:who like to see some about AV,and where can i find seo for better 网站排名

test comment..

 

Re: If a boat ends up on a reef… Tonga Report 3

Ohh no:(
 

お迎え付きです

 

流行の先端

 

ビジネスチャンス

 

簡単在宅バイト

 

期間限定イベント案内

 

エッチ度を気軽に診断

 

仕事帰りに彼氏のお家へ

 

急募逆援助交際会員

 

秘められたモテ度を暴く

 

Account Login

Media Centers

Syndication feeds

 

This site made manifest by dadaIMC software