Aotearoa IMC : http://indymedia.org.nz
Aotearoa IMC

LOCAL News :: Animal Rights

Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

Saturday 19 January 2008
Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist
Media Release: Open Rescue Collective
Open Rescue Collective activist Mark Eden is facing burglary charges relating to the November 2006 rescue of 20 battery hens from Turk's Poultry, an intensive egg farm in Foxton owned by Ron Turk.

Eden's jury trial, scheduled for late 2008, will be the first of its kind in New Zealand. Eden is challenging the property status of animals under the Animal Welfare Act 1999. He maintains that by removing battery hens from Turks farm, he was mitigating suffering, not stealing property.

Eden says "Jim Anderton's over-ruling of the Parliament's Regulations Review Committee's 2006 decision that battery cages are actually in breach of the Animal Welfare Act is outrageous considering that a 2002 Colmar Brunton survey showed 79 per cent of New Zealanders thought battery cages unacceptable, and wanted them banned".

"Since Jim Anderton so blatantly disregards breaches of legislation, why should members of Open Rescue abide by so-called animal welfare legislation that does nothing to protect animals but in fact protects the industries that abuse them? Animals are afforded no rights under the Act and are deemed as nothing more than property to be owned and exploited".

"Open Rescue activists rescued 15 battery hens in Auckland just before Christmas and more recently rescued 31 battery hens from appalling conditions in Christchurch. Its great to see caring people take direct and compassionate action for animals on factory farms. I fully support the actions of these people and know there will be many more rescues in 2008."

Mark Eden and Open Rescue supporters will be staging a protest today outside the Turks Poultry Slaughterhouse at 11am, urging consumers to boycott cruel caged eggs.

ENDS

NOTES

(1) Turks Poultry Slaughterhouse, State Highway One, Foxton.

(2) Mr. Eden is pleading not guilty to the theft of the hens from the intensive egg farm. The 20 hens were rescued from horrendous conditions on Turk's farm in November 2006 and were placed into new homes for rehabilitation.

(3) The New Zealand Open Rescue Collective formed in 2006 after New Zealand activists became immensely frustrated with the Government's lack of real action for animals on factory farms.

20 years of campaigning against factory farming using legal means such as protesting and lobbying saw little to no changes for animals.

The Collective's aims are to openly rescue animals from places of abuse, to expose hidden suffering and to consistently provide irrefutable evidence why factory farming should be banned.
 
 
Comment on this article
Title
Author Anonymous
  Create a new account ?
Text Format

Comment

Anti-spam Enter the following number into the box:
To add more detailed comments, or to upload files, see the full comment form.

Comments

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

Munch respect to all open rescue groups around the country. Unashamed civil disobedience is the best way to challenge legalized injustice without being branded as "terrorists".

Martin Crowe
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

Stay strong Marky!
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

"without being branded as "terrorists"."

Er no they still brand you as terrorists either way. Poltical activists are seen by the state, on a base level, as criminals who express their criminality through politically charged activities. The so called 'activist database' is handled by the same organisation who job is to keep tabs on international terrorist activity in relation to NZ...the SIS.
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

Animal Rights activists are NOT terrorists.
I'm yet to know anyone who has harmed a soul
(human or otherwise) in their "politically charged activities".
By the way SIS = Superstitious Ignorant Spooks.
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

Ha! Ha! Mark's in trouble. Serves him right being a pawn by someone who plays it SAFE in Oz.
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

Political speeches won’t work in court.
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

"Ha! Ha! Mark's in trouble. Serves him right for being a pawn for someone who plays it SAFE in Oz."

The Safe loon in Brisbane is an unpleasant chap. He has forgotten: it’s nice to be important but it is more important to be nice. He tried to get me to do illegal stuff while he stayed safe in his office when I was involved with Safe but I didn’t have a bar of it. It’s because of him it's why I dropped the animal rights movement in Aotearoa and got involved with it in the United Kingdom.
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

"Political speeches won’t work in court. "

No, but legal arguments will. It is a defence in law to use minimum force to prevent a crime, and taking the hens is preventing a crime under the Animal Welfare Act. the Regulations Review Committee, made up of MPs from all parties, some of whom had been on the committee that helped enact the Animal Welfare Act, unanimously agreed that the code fo welfare for layer hens was in breach of the Act. Teh government arrogantly ignored the committees findings following legal threats and bullying from the battery egg industry.

Open rescue are not breaking the law, they are upholding it.

Phil
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

"The Safe loon in Brisbane is an unpleasant chap..."

I had problems with this person too. That is why I dumped SAFE and I am now associated with the AAA. I find direct action works better for the AR cause that upholding a fiefdom.

In any case, good luck Mark and good call Phil.
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

"Open rescue are not breaking the law, they are upholding it."

I didn't know that anyone could uphold one law while breaking a number of others i.e. trespassing and thief. And what gives the legal right for the NZ Open Rescue Collective to take the law into their own hands?
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

Happens all the time. A drunk cop driving to a car crash. Does the cop do their job or technically stay home and let the crashees die.
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

"I find direct action works better for the AR cause than upholding a fiefdom."

The people at Safe and the rest of the animal rights activists are no different than anyone else. All what they want to do is build up empires so they can control other people's thoughts and actions, just so they can make more money while keeping the rest of us in poverty. Is this any different from any other type of capitalist venture or other parts of society? I for one don't appreciate others trying to do my thinking and feeling for me and so shouldn't you!
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

"Happens all the time. A drunk cop driving to a car crash. Does the cop do their job or technically stay home and let the crashees die."

What a pathetic argument: if everyone else jumps off a cliff you should too.
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

SAFE is nothing but a pitiful lobby organisation that only does the token gesture at protesting for animal rights. They have rebranded and called themselves an animal advocacy group but there is little evidence that they do even that. It is best avoided and for you to stick with any other group that actually does direct action against animal abuse. Go ALF, AAA and Open Rescue!!!
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

"What a pathetic argument: if everyone else jumps off a cliff you should too."

Im not sure you got my point, so Ill say it again, this time read what Im saying here with two eyes...open.

If saving a life means breaking the law to do so, would you:
A) be a souless armchair maggot and do nothing because you may be breaking the law, or,
B) Since its a life were talking about in a senario situation of life and death, and of course, you have a soul...the law then is irrelevant so you act.

Lets just say for arguments sake, that life were discussing is a human life. Your answer please.
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

I hope that when you eat your next KFC,Tegel chicken ,Signiture Range and all the other brand from provider of poultry meat, you think about,maybe what you are stuffing down your gob,was probably mistreated and riddled by decease from contaminated enviroments that these birds prolonged too.

Also some of these Poultry Farms are not washing their Egg,before selling to the consumer,which makes this a hygiene issue. Wait till Birdflu starts rearing it ugly head here,then you ses will start crying
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

The biggest Terrorist in this Country are the gutless wonders,who label others as terrorist
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

you know for a small country with only 4 million ppl there sure is alot of animal activism,admire you guys,just wish we could have it here in AUS the animal rights "movement" is restricted to one or two handful of ppl actually doing something,really frustrating
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

hi
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

I would rather protect the animal, as they have no one to speak for them, then the nutcase politician and their follower,they couldn't care a shit about Animal Welfare and Animal Rights,if we start mistreating animals,watch who starts shitting their pants and starts cry fowl
 

Re: Compassion not burglary, says battery hen activist

There are legal precedents for the defence of reasonable force in criminal law. A Christian group in the UK called Operation Ploughshares broke into an air field, did millions of pounds worth of damage to an airforce plane, then handed themselves in to the police. In court they pleased not guilty to wilful damage on the basis they were preventing a crime. The crime they were preventing was genocide, which is a criminal offence under international law. They argued that the plane was going to be sent to Indonesia, and the Indonesian military would be using it to commit genocide in East Timor.

The jury agreed with their legal defence, and those who damaged the plane were aquitted.

There are plenty of other examples as well as the above case and the drunken cop one. The most obvious would be using minimum force to prevent someone else being raped, assulted, murdered. What do you think we should do in this situation. Wag our finger at them? Wait for the police to arrive, by which time someone is dead? Similarly with the raids on battery farms. The SPCA do their best, but they have limited resources and cannot prosecute every establishment that breaches the Animal Welfare Act.
 

Account Login

Media Centers

Syndication feeds

 

This site made manifest by dadaIMC software